Church Livestreaming and ID Checks: Kenya's Data Privacy Debate
As churches increasingly livestream services and buildings introduce identity checks for visitors, questions are emerging about how much personal information Kenyans should be required to share. Outgoing Data Commissioner Immaculate Kassait says organisations must distinguish between collecting personal information and obtaining meaningful consent.
0 likes
The growing use of digital technology in Kenya has renewed debate over the right to privacy, particularly when churches, commercial buildings and other institutions collect personal information from members of the public.
From visitors being asked to provide their national identification numbers and telephone contacts before entering buildings to worshippers appearing in livestreamed church services without clearly understanding how their images will be used, everyday activities are raising important questions about data protection.
In an interview with She Means Business, Kenya's first Data Commissioner, Immaculate Kassait, reflected on these challenges as she prepares to leave office after serving a six-year non-renewable term at the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC).
Kassait emphasised that collecting personal information does not automatically mean an organisation has obtained valid consent from the individual concerned.
She explained that notices and acceptance of terms and conditions do not necessarily amount to informed consent. Organisations must clearly communicate why information is being collected and how it will be used.
Can Buildings Demand Your ID Number and Phone Number?
One of the major privacy concerns facing Kenyans involves buildings and commercial establishments that require visitors to provide personal details before being allowed entry.
While security remains an important consideration, organisations collecting identification numbers, telephone contacts and other personal information must have a legitimate and clearly communicated reason for doing so.
Kenya's Data Protection Act, 2019, requires organisations to process personal information lawfully, fairly and transparently.
The law also emphasises data minimisation, meaning institutions should only collect information that is necessary for the specific purpose for which it is required.
Consequently, organisations should be able to explain why they need a visitor's identification number, how the information will be stored, who can access it and how long it will be retained.
Simply asking visitors to provide personal information as a routine administrative requirement does not remove an organisation's responsibilities under data protection law.
Can Churches Livestream Services Without Congregants' Consent?
The increasing popularity of online worship has created another privacy challenge for religious institutions.
Many churches across Kenya broadcast Sunday services, worship sessions, prayer meetings and special events through Facebook, YouTube and other digital platforms.
Although livestreaming allows churches to reach members who cannot attend physically, it also raises questions about the privacy of people appearing in the recordings.
A worshipper attending a church service may not necessarily expect their face, voice or participation to be broadcast to thousands of online viewers.
The ODPC's guidance on publishing recorded media emphasises the importance of transparency, a lawful basis for processing personal information and appropriate safeguards when recording and publishing images and videos.
Churches should therefore inform congregants about livestreaming arrangements, explain how recordings will be used and consider measures that protect individuals who do not wish to appear on camera.
Practical safeguards include positioning cameras towards the pulpit, creating areas outside camera coverage and obtaining appropriate consent from identifiable individuals who are deliberately featured.
The Office's guidance also gives an example of a church that streams sermons while deliberately keeping the congregation outside the camera's view.
This demonstrates how religious institutions can continue using digital platforms without unnecessarily exposing worshippers' personal information.
Can Shopping Malls Use Visitors' Photographs for Marketing?
Another issue concerns shopping malls and commercial establishments that photograph visitors and subsequently publish the images on social media platforms for promotional purposes.
While businesses may use photography to document events and promote their services, the use of identifiable photographs involves processing personal data.
The purpose for which an image is collected matters.
For example, photographs taken for security purposes should not automatically be repurposed for advertising without an appropriate lawful basis and compliance with data protection requirements.
Businesses must consider whether individuals have been adequately informed, whether the intended use is lawful and whether appropriate consent or another valid legal basis exists.
The distinction between security monitoring, documenting public events and using personal photographs for commercial promotion is therefore important.
Worldcoin Controversy Tested Kenya's Data Protection Framework
During her six years in office, Kassait oversaw several major data protection challenges involving the collection, use and commercialisation of personal information.
One of the most significant was the Worldcoin controversy, which involved the collection of Kenyans' iris biometric information in exchange for cryptocurrency.
Biometric information is particularly sensitive because it relates to unique physical characteristics that can be used to identify individuals.
The controversy raised questions about informed consent, the handling of sensitive personal information and the responsibilities of organisations collecting biometric data.
Another major challenge involved B2BHint, a Moldova-based company linked to the exposure and commercialisation of Kenyan company records accessed through Business Registration Service data.
The case highlighted the difficulties of enforcing national data protection laws when personal information is processed or commercialised across international borders.
Artificial Intelligence Raises New Privacy Concerns Ahead of 2027 Elections
Kassait also highlighted emerging risks associated with artificial intelligence, particularly the potential misuse of personal information in political targeting and manipulation.
As Kenya approaches the 2027 General Election, concerns are growing about how personal data could be used to profile voters, influence political messaging and distribute targeted content.
Her previous experience as Director of Voter Registration at the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) gives her additional insight into the relationship between personal information and electoral processes.
The growing availability of digital information means that organisations and political actors must remain accountable for how they collect, analyse and use people's data.
What Rights Do Kenyans Have Under the Data Protection Act?
Kenya's Data Protection Act, 2019, establishes several rights for individuals whose personal information is collected and processed.
These include:
- Right to be informed: Individuals have a right to know when their personal information is being collected and how it will be used.
- Right to access: People can request access to their personal information held by an organisation.
- Right to object: Individuals can object to certain forms of personal data processing.
- Right to correction: People can request the correction of inaccurate or misleading personal information.
- Right to deletion: Individuals can request the deletion of personal information in circumstances provided for under the law.
- Protection against unlawful processing: Organisations must have a lawful basis for collecting and using personal information.
Kenyans who believe their personal information has been mishandled can raise complaints with the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner.
The Bigger Question: How Much of Our Privacy Are We Giving Up?
As Kenya becomes increasingly digital, the balance between security, convenience, commercial interests and individual privacy is becoming more important.
Churches want to reach larger audiences through online broadcasts. Businesses want to improve security and promote their services. Property managers want to know who enters their premises.
However, these objectives must be balanced against the rights of individuals.
Kassait's reflections highlight an important principle: having access to someone's personal information does not give an organisation unlimited permission to use it.
The challenge ahead is ensuring that institutions understand their legal responsibilities while Kenyans become more aware of their rights.
Ultimately, protecting personal information is not simply a responsibility of regulators. It requires accountability from organisations and greater awareness among members of the public.
Share this story
Choose a platform or copy the link